School of Webcraft meeting pad
School of Webcraft community call now shares the same time and call in information as the P2PU Community Call.
Please visit http://pad.p2pu.org/community for more information
Where necessary we'll convene Webcraft specific calls and continue to use this pad for keeping those notes.
Erin and Pippa -
- reaching out to external orgs - OWEA, Python etc
- how best to do this
- email draft - erin to draft
- Main descriptions of project
- Communication plan for SoW Q2-beginning Q3
- continuous badge content
- pushing osqa pilot - ASAP - end May
- ongoing study groups / ended study groups
- current participants and incoming
- then in june - announcement list and blog
- Lernanta support for badges
- final task for groups - link to appropriate badge ***
- Module - point to relevent assessments from Group page - June?
- Batacuda / Lernanta either / or?
- Full integration - all hosted within Lernanta - 3rd Quarter
- http://pad.p2pu.org/SoWTalkingPoints
- [Pippa]
- how to set up a group on lernanta for SoW
- is there a badge?
- if so - link
- if not - suggest a badge
- Authority Guru badge / self-identified expert outreach
- naming it
- specialists in "thing"
- Alex Halavais, Ahrash, David Bruant, John Resig, P2PU Community
- information to request
- 2nd stage: tasks outside of study groups
- [task - pippa & erin] question ideas for Guru / Authority badge
- questions to ask
- goals: clarifying badge content, curating related content and tasks, introducing them to SoW and ideally leading a group
- framing this so that we get the best responses, but don't demand too much guru time
- Webcraft focus - but suitable for broader community gurus
- how to assess this
- peers / us?
- identifying good responses
Telephone Numbers
- Canada +1 416 848 3114 Ext. 92 Conference number 7600#
- US or Intl. +1 650 903 0800 Ext. 92 Conference number 7600#
- US Toll-Free +1 800 707 2533 PW 369 Conference number 7600#
- International: if you have Skype credit, we recommend calling the US Toll-Free number.
join #education on irc.mozilla.org for chat at non-community call times. irc.mozilla.org #education
All weekly working calls are open to the community and you are free to add items to the agenda, ask questions and participate in discussions.
If you can only make calls infrequently we recommend joining on the third Thursday of every month.
Bookmark this page to have access to the current agenda and live note taking!
Archived notes here: https://wiki.mozilla.org/Drumbeat/p2pu/weekly_call
THURSDAY 3rd January 2011===================
THURSDAY 27th January 2011=================
Attendees:
Jessica Ledbetter (Virginia)
Pippa Buchanan (Adelaide, Australia)
Dan Diebolt (Ann Arbor, Michigan)
Erin Knight (Oaktown, CA)
Andy Lindeman (Huntsville, Alabama USA)
Notes
Probably on current platform in April -- if some courses willing to test it then maybe
Perhaps review process for April courses (need volunteers from the community)
does co-facilitation help future organisers?
JL - sandbox experience with admin features of course organisation
Andy - sharing learning process
[task] Is there a dev server that course orgs can practice in? +1000000
- exporting course design / importing between servers?
- make playing with website part of orientation - setup a course, apply to courses, review sign-ups etc
[task] plans for documenting backend and user end of new site?
BigBlueButton+1+1
Erin - badges and assessment
[task] pippa to look at erin's spreadsheet
Feb 21st - release the hounds (with bees in their mouths) / release assessments
in separate OSQA setup for pilot testing purposes
course orgs to direct their participants to assessments
peer assessments, votes from OSQA setup
badges exported to P2PU profile
community badges - adding recommendations in the profiles eg. teammate, communicator
OSQA developer back, alternative developers
working with absolutely, absolutely must-haves
AWESOME!
Course Wishlist
Front End
Semantics
Database
Course Ideas - fleshout the portfolio of what school of webcraft offers
need to move into the design arena - layouts, wireframes, color, font, etc
course in CSS, frameworks Mootools, YUI, jQuery UI, etc
mysql, other database
node.js - if you can find someone to organize it and have a way to share code (heroku has such a service but they were bought by salesforce)
Nodester [ http://nodester.com/ ] is an option (beta and free currently .. hopefully a free tier will remain?)
Andy Lindeman would potentially really like to help with this :)
website optimization
standards compliance
HTML5 - lots of subtopics for several 6 week courses
make sure that the really voted up suggestions happen? (course recommendation thing)
(ideal use of osqa/uservoice tool) - http://p2pu.uservoice.com/forums/84091-course
Yep, that's the thing!
different levels -suggestions
- beginner HTML, CSS, Javascript
- advanced HTML, CSS, Javascript
- accessibility
- beginner python
- advanced python -- django :)
- and how to contribute to open source (this one)
take X and get X badge
[task] connect with below about defining experience levels
MDN - course surveying
OWEA -
projects -
at the end of 6 weeks what is your outcome / project?
[task] frame question to community
what is a good learning outcome ? how to identify within the projects that act as goals?
Facilitator Hopeful Experience/Outcome
Professional training? Learning more about topic that facilitating? Tshirt? Certificate? References? (We are going to get some recommendations for the badges.)
Reward ideas.
Maybe at the end of the course: survey if put facilitator experience on CV
JavaScript Course designs - http://pad.p2pu.org/webcraftJavaScriptCourseDesigns
Trying Big Blue Button as meeting environment?
THURSDAY 13 January 2011 ======= WEBCRAFT ORGANISERS ORIENTATION ====
Topics:
- Running Webcraft Courses
- Assessments and Badges ( summary walking through today: http://wiki.p2pu.org/w/page/34853186/Webcraft-Assessment )
- Pre-flight checklist for course leaders http://bit.ly/flSTCY
- Question for course leaders: is this documentation helpful?
- What other key questions do we need to clarify & document?
- e.g., How to review applications
- Question for leaners
- How do we make it clearer / easier for you to get what you need?
Attendees:
Erin Knight (Berkeley, CA!)
Andy Lindeman (Huntsville, Alabama USA)
Jessica Ledbetter (Virginia)
Matt Buscemi (Honolulu, HI)
Nate Gandomi (Berkeley, CA - sitting right next to Erin!)
Pippa Buchanan (currently in Sydney)
Naty Caamal (Miami, Fl)
Matt Thompson, (Mozilla Drumbeat)
Dan Diebolt (Ann Arbor Michigan)
Marielle Volz (Ann Arbor Michigan)
Shane Tomlinson(London)
Notes:
Pippa: Most of what I'm covering is in this document: http://wiki.p2pu.org/w/page/34243004/Designing-a-Course-for-School-of-Webcraft
Please take rough notes though, particularly around questions so I can update the document where fit.
Erin: I'll be covering the assessment and badge pilot, pulling from here: http://wiki.p2pu.org/w/page/34853186/Webcraft-Assessment
School of Webcraft: partnership between P2PU and Mozilla to provide peer learning opportunities for web development
Running a course:
We have a running, working list of open resources and course models for Web development technologies - please refer to them, great resources for where they fit
Questions:
Thursday 7 January 2011 =================================
People in Call
Andy Lindeman
Dan Diebolt
Ozzie
Pippa
Matt Thompson
Shane
Tina
Hasan
Agenda
How do we provide awesome customer service for the January semester?
1) Finalize School of Webcraft January course list
- GOAL: Have course list finalized by Monday, Jan 10
- 19 SoW courses currently listed here: http://p2pu.org/webcraft/
- There may be more. Some p2pu courses may not have been tagged "webcraft"
- TASK: Someone with P2PU admin access needs to tag.
2) Help course leaders get ready for Jan 26
- Send email to course organizers
- Let's craft an email and blog post that provides clear step-by-step instructions on what course leaders need to do next.
- 1) Sign up for a Course Design Orientation session
- http://p2pu.org/general/course-design-orientation
- QUESTIONS
- This page asks four questions at the bottom. Where / how do course leaders provide the answers?
- If I was a course leader, I'd find the current process of signing up for a Course Design Orientation session a bit confusing. Does "signing up for a session" just involve adding my name to the "When is Good" form?
- 2) Check out the Course Design Handbook
- 3) Establish a "sign-up task" for your course
- 4) [What else?]
- What else should course leaders be thinking about to get ready?
- Over-relying on TokBox video chat seemed to be a major source of problems last semester. How can we avoid that this time around?
- 5) Get ready for blast off!
- Your course will begin the week of Jan 26
- 2) How do we make the registration process clearer and easier for learners?
- When will registration open?
- 1) What's available? 2) When do they start? 3) What's the sign-up task? 4) Ask questions to the course organizer before applying.
- become a member of P2PU to communicate with course organisers
- MAILING LISTS THAT CURRENTLY EXIST
- p2pu-webcraftannounce, p2pu-webcraft, drumbeat webcraft list - exported
- How does it work?
- You need to complete a sign-up task.
- You'll hear back on whether you've been accepted into the course by: [date]
- What's the current workflow / user experience like? How can we simplify it?
- What's our communication plan?
- What sort of advertising should be done for courses? Are course organizers responsible for getting the word out about their course in the relevant places?
- Probably don't need to do much promotion at this point -- demand already exceeds space
- 3) How do we guarantee a smooth first week of classes and satisfied course leaders / learners at end of semester?
- What did we learn from user feedback last semester?
- Try to avoid TokBox unless absolutely necessary (video chat)
- Many people got off track or missed something early on in the course. Make it easy for people to go back to the original course starting point to catch up. Vital information needs to appear on course homepage. Course homepage should be the starting point with a "trail of breadcrumbs" on how to get up to speed / reset.
- Need a Review process. Like a book where you can go back to chapter 1 if necessary -- even if the rest of the class is on chapter 12.
- Updating School of Webcraft landing page http://p2pu.org/webcraft/
- e.g., Remove "propose a course" button. [pippa-task for p2pu-dev]
- Update text. [pippa - task]
- Swtich from emphasis on proposing courses to applying for courses
- "Take a course" date is incorrect per recent discussion (should be 12 Jan)
- Updated course list (will be ready Monday)
- Add a nice image if possible. [Matt to email to Pippa for inclusion with text]!
- MObile friendly version! < can we delay that til Lernanta?
- Make it clearer how Mozilla / Drumbeat / P2PU all mesh together
- A simple drawing / infographic would help
- One thing missing for a new user coming to the page is WHY - WHY should they take a course here, and why should they trust the information they find here? What is in it for the learner?
- Mention badges as a way to show on resume/CV?+1
FEEDBACK / SUGGESTIONS FOR APRIL SEMESTER:
course orientation should happen BEFORE course design takes place.
Questions to add to School of Webcraft FAQ
Existing FAQ: http://p2pu.org/webcraft/school-webcraft-frequently-asked-questions
- Questions about signup process
- How does feedback from potential participant get back to course organizer? email, forum? Is it a private message participant to facilitator or public?
- Can some type of email be sent to people who voted on uservoice about course starting and registration? Process and data is disconnected from p2pu.org [TASK - Pippa)
- Any ideas how we can improve accessibility to html5 courses? On the draft course list there only seems to be one course but is in Spanish. There was alot of buzz about html5 in the discussion group.
- we're working with Mozilla Developer Network to draft a course to run in March / April
- Can we recommend any existing January courses for those interested in html5 which can also act as a good pre-cursor for an html5 course in March/April?
- How many classes can people sign up for?
- Answer: As many as you like. But we can't guarantee that you'll be able to get into them. Be aware that each course will require around 3 - 5 hours per week in terms of time commitment. So be aware of that before you take on multiple courses. More than 2 courses at a time is probably unweildy.
- How do Mozilla / Drumbeat / P2PU all fit together?
- Why should I take a course here? Why should I trust the information I find here? What's in it for me? What's the value proposition?
Thursday 30 December 2010 =================================
Attendees
Matt, Mozilla
Agenda
- Course proposals and course organisation
- any help you need?
- suggestions for other organisers
- status of offers to help facilitate courses (dfelber, Mattea, Tomlinson, Phillips)?
- How to best take up offers to facilitate?
- ASsessments and Badges (Erin)
- How to use (and improve) P2PU's QA system.
- Mailing List status
Attendees
Pippa (Berlin, Australian, but currently in Dunedin, NZ)
Erin
Matt Buscemi (Hawaii)
Alison Cole
Andy Lindeman
Dan Diebolt (Ann Arbor Michigan)
COURSES
- sign up for orientation! http://p2pu.org/general/course-design-orientation
- read the (awesome) Handbook! http://wiki.p2pu.org/Course-Design-Handbook
- important to have a weekly plan for each week of the course
- Old P2PU courses:
- Andy: concerned that it will either be too fast or too slow and overwhelming
- Erin: common problem
- important to get the course community involved in giving you feedback
- set up a social contract
- get initial feedback on plan
- continuously review this with participants
- do this the first week and focus on creating the community and weeding out those that aren't willing to participate or were just checking out the course
- Dan: delivery
- overwhelmed with course interest
- can we have co-facilitators
- Pippa: recommend having fewer people so that you can foster the peer-to-peer connection and interaction needed
- what's the optimal number?
- depends on what you want to do in the course
- if want synchronous components (tokbox, etc), over 20 gets difficult
- if asynchronous, you can probably handle more
- also remember that there will be dropouts
- let in 40 if you want 20 to stick
- those that aren't participating after the 2nd week, probably are not going to ever start
- doing the social contract (see above) the first week can help set expectations and get to the core people that are
- New forum for SoW: http://qa.p2pu.org (OSQA instance, open source version of Stack Overflow)
- recommend using to manage course questions/discussions, especially if you have larger numbers
- suggest that participants pair up into study-buddy groups and have a partner to be
- Assessments and Badges
- currently no externally viewed credits / assessments
- how can we capture the learning that's going on and provide a way for them to take it from place to place
- job interviews etc
- should also help deal with drop outs - there's something more significant to work towards
- JavasScript, Accessibility, CommunitySkills in OSQA,
- PHP Badges:
- Matt Buscemi: for php assessment, I imagine three tiers of badges:
- 1) can build simple, dynamic webpages
- 2) can incorporate SQL and/or NoSQL databases into existing webpages,
- 3) can apply OOP and other organizational patterns to projects -- I think all of these can be exemplified by personal projects
- This could be roughly applied to Ruby on Rails?
- Mailing List Status?
- Timing for course orientation
Thursday 23 December 2010 ==============================
- How do we manage 6000 new people?
- Run a survey through the community to find out what they're interested in (Charlie)
- Indian community member has problem with how to communicate Webcraft and P2PU to his website readers
- Ozzie - training, how do you communicate? This is a little like Social Media, it used to be a hidden thing is now very popular
- This is like compuserve or a usenet list but live and more formalised
- we have to come up with a better analogy
- This is like how we learned prior to going to school for the first time we learned from our peers. little brother, sisters, parents. The early days the newsgroups and listserver filled the void for peer learning. This was more out of needs rather than cost. This is bringing peer learning to web 2.0 ?
- People struggle with peer learning because the result can be abstract and the perception is that learning is not occuring because the milestones are a variable rather than being a static result.
- Its not for everyone , just like college you get what you put into it.
- Turnover speed compared to formal learning
- for a lot of technical topics by the time you get a university course approved and the textbook printed the topic is out of date
- This is about learning, not about getting bums on seats for government funding or sales for textbooks
- Booki.cc http://www.booki.cc/ a way to build our own text books and collaboratively author and publish them (with an open license eg CC-By-SA)
- maybe for cloud computing?
- P2PU.org - is in drupal
- new system in Python/Django
- p2pu-dev@googlegroups.com
Attendees
Charlie LA
Dan Diebolt
Dipankar?
Pippa (Australia)
Bill O'Connor (NYC)
GTK developer, keeping eye on moving target
HTML5 for Gnome
- Ozzie Sutcliffe NYC also
- I am looking to learn basic HTML and JavaScript. I am an ITSM Process Engineer and the SAAS application I work uses a bunch of JavaScript so I need to understand enough to be dangerous.
- thru internal yammer
NOTES
Tuesday 21 December 2010==============================
Agenda
- Awesome - we got amazing coverage, now what do we do?
- Mailing Lists - discussion and announce
- Is Google Groups the appropriate tool for announcements?
- Now 6,000+ people in Google Group
- People unsubscribing because of too much noise
- Question:
- Do we a) keep them there or b) move to announce list?
- What is our workflow for sign-ups before registration opens?
- Google groups restricts our control - can't easily move or subscribe masses of people (other mailing list options?)
- How best to "convert" course ideas?
- How do we ensure people who proposed courses get supported and convert into real courses?
- Triage course proposals. Identify high-priority proposals.
- Low-priority proposals: Gently punt to next semester. Encourage them to participate in a January semester course. Or help out with / T.A. a course that's similar.
- less prepared courses to be dealt with gently, work on your next draft
- save a list of people to invite to the
- Communicate with priority course proposers through individual follow-up.
- Match priority course proposals with potential P2PU mentors. Cluster similar proposals with the same mentor.
- Encourage them to refine their idea and fill out course template on P2PU site
- Provide example of strong completed course template
- e.g., Jessy Cowan-Sharp's "Reading Code". John Britton's class.
ACTIONS
- HTML5 / CSS3 Asynchronous course
- http://pad.p2pu.org/webcraftHTML5CSSAsynch
- who would design it?
- who would run it?
- What Mark imagines
- spend money on course design and course management
- Can we contact MDN for help (Stormy, Janet etc)
- Use section leaders to either facilitate time-based or location / language groups
- Maintain 6 week modules
- sections of peer groups (20-25 people in each section)
- timezone clustering
- first come first serve (once have 20-25 in a timezone, if have facilitator, then that section is a go, if not, ask one of the 20-25 to facilitate)
- do we maintain a sign-up exercise?
- volunteer facilitators
- shared portfolio and project gallery across all sections
- badges
- assessments/badges for the end of the course
- maybe more granular/incremental badges for activities/milestones within the course
- course facilitator badges
- Big demand for basic Web Dev 101 style learning in Philipino, Indonesian, Spanish etc
- better if we do a really good remix of WaSP for larger asynchronous groups
- this can be translated and retain some quality
- badges
- Server fundraising? Use this influx as a way to get support
- User experience / workflow: review process for a) taking a course b) proposing a course
- this will be vastly improved post new-P2PU system
- ACTIONS
- speculating and specifying a rough outline of how these courses would work
- pick one or two topics
- possible for January 26th?
- xmas / nye break or early January
- contact with Stormy - can she delegate an MDN person to work on this
- Tantek / Heilmann work on content design
- be ready to fail
- Mark's questions
- Do we have a plan to close all the offers to run courses?
- What to simple things can we do to make sure courses go well?
- Pippa says: fix the mailing list?
- John's questsions
- How do we deal with HUGE demand for specific courses? +1+1
- quality
- ability to translate
Notes from Philipp:
== OSQA / Assessment ==
* We are planning to use OSQA to prototype Erin's assessment models (and expose badges). To that end, we are looking for a python/django resource urgently and would appreciate help finding someone.
** I had hoped to make more progress working with Josh on this, but he ended up looking at other things related to badges. Unfortunately that means we have to find someone who can get started fast (ideally with OSQA experience).
** I am happy to fund short-term (Jan/Feb) or could grow into lead developer position.
** Is there a possibility to get some of Brian's time in January to put into this? It would be focused on the producer/issuer piece of the infrastructure work. We'd use OpenID + OSQA to expose badges from P2PU OSQA server.
== What to do with the Mashable Masses ==
* I like Geoff's idea of running 101 entry courses that qualify you for 201 - and we could apply that to HTML5
* Other ways to leverage the huge influx of people
16 December 2010 ==============================
Agenda
- Call for courses update
- FAQ
- Badges and Assessment (Erin)
Present
Andy Lindeman (first time caller, mailing list member)
Erin
Matt Thompson, Mozilla
Pippa
Ben Moskowitz
Tina Arnoldi (first time caller)
Dan
Notes
call for courses
- - difficult for us to reach 30 courses
- Andy: motivations and how you heard about it
- John Britton contributed on another OS Project
- Ruby on Rails top voted Uservoice course
- retweeted
- has experience in RoR
- TWITTER
- Ben: nathan has the mailing list from festival
- learning , freedom and the web
- Hastac - DUKES Campus
- MIT - OCW
- Mozilla channels - Stormy's
- Janet and Jay to blog on MDN
- ITP & like
- Pippa primary TASK Fri AM- email 700+ interested
COURSES
- Tenets of Web Privacy -
- Facilitating Hack events
FAQs
draft: links above
putting Tina on the spot :) - what is the time commitment for course facilitators? (check!)
do people understand organizing - do they expect to get something tangible (money, etc)?
do people feel like they need to be an expert?
what are people's motivations for running a course? self-learners/DIY supporters, experience, passionate about course topics (<---good for messaging!)
would be great to get more questions - to understand people's impressions and questions about SoW
where should the FAQs live? drumbeat page (can refer to it from P2PU)
Badges and Assessment
rundown: as of now in SoW and P2PU there is no assessment
no credits, no grades, little feedback
People are taking courses just to learn
participants need a way to signal this to the outside world
if i do a course, how can i present this on a CV?
this is not just a problem in P2PU but everywhere in non-formal learning
Our solution to this is badges: badges capture people's experience and guide them down a learning path
Mozilla Badge Backpack: ways of collecting and displaying badges like a boyscout shirt
SoW is creating assessments linked to badges
This is a challenge!
P2PU is an experiment
pilot of assessments for January round
- Erin and Pippa working with the community to identify what badges they'd like
currently focusing on JavaScript Expert and Accessibility
- will call on course organisers to develop badges specific to their courses
- peer given badges
- automatic community behaviour badges (eg Question Asker)
What is a JavaScript Expert?
we put this out to the community and received approval (1 email)
challenge
rubric based on expert skills
rubric can be compared to an existing project or developers can work on a specific assessment badge
peers to approve
JavaScript Basic Badge
- peer assessed,
- open ended JavaScript challenges
- light weight JS exercises
if you can get this to run without bugs you've been successful
Accessibility
- values and attitudes
- personal reflection , blog post, video etc
- we have accessibility evangelists
we'll give known experts a badge and they can then pass the badge onto community members who have this attitude
General Badges that can be shared
Tina:
learn wordpress beyond a blog
understanding templates
basic PHP within courses
Q. Are organisers going to receive badges?
Good crossovers with an alternative conversation on P2PU - they have most likely developed a lot of skills that would be good on a CV
badges for successful completion of courses
should achievements have points? accumulate points values - see in aggregate (maybe for post pilot build)
motivation
could introduce a negative dynamic
but something to think about once we get more badges across levels
give course organizers a badge for running a course
people are super excited about badges - might motivate them to run courses
09 December 2010
Agenda
- SoW Communications Roadmap
- January Call for courses
- How to push harder and get out to more people
- Badge and ASsessment ideas
- recommending the MIT License
- New Community Call times?
- Pippa's blogging about SoW: Planet Webcraft, Planet Drumbeat, Planet Mozilla, LFW
- Updating p2pu webcraft landing page: http://p2pu.org/webcraft
- Specific Fundraising task for SoW
SoW Communications Roadmap
Are potential contributors finding it difficult to learn about SoW?
What are the jury rigging things we can do now?
Deciding what the primary location is?
Bespoke site that is custom made for SoW (other Drumbeat projects to have same focus)
Main use cases:
what is the project
how can i get involved > Learn More
running a course > Run a Course
participating in a course > Join a Course
[TASK - Update existing content on Drumbeat]
[TASK - Matt and Pippa to work on Copy]
Story focus - Drumbeat.org
Learning focus - P2PU.org
How seamless can the transition between these pages?
How do we communicate that there is a transition and why?
January Call for Courses
Specific Course Ideas
- Technology of WikiLeaks
- WebMadeMovies - Popcorn.js
- run by one of Humph's students
- reach out through Brett and humph
- Audio course (also from Humph's students)
- Processing.js - can we get another one of Ari and JD's students to organise
- Wordpress course
- Pippa: write short post / Mark will forward on
- Christian Heilmann to blog and retweet [Pippa to connect with directly]
- MDN connection: what stuff will come out of Webinar series?
- HTML5 / FF4 course? (Erin to explore at all-hands)
- Pippa to push call via past course organisers
* Outreach to specific people / communities
** course leaders from last semester?
Important dates
Registration opens Jan 8
Courses Jan 26 (join webcraft mailing list)
Finding a new blogging location for School of Webcraft
http://learninglearning.wordpress.com/
- using the tag "p2pu-webcraft"
- choose between "mozilla" "drumbeat" "P2PU" "webcraft"
- use School of Webcraft as default naming convention
[Pippa email ATOM feed links for different planet - cc Matt and Paul Osman, Stian for webcraft]
- more images in blog
Fundraising around server?
Donate to School of Webcraft link:
https://donate.mozilla.org/page/contribute/webcraft
- blog post [Pippa: before Monday]
This Week: 24 November 2010
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Call Focus: First Round of Assessments: JavaScript and Accessiblity
Please add notes and links even if you can't make the call.
David Bruant
* What are the fundamental things about JavaScript that you wish you'd known when you first started as a developer?
=> I think that JS is a sum of a lot of technologies and that web dev should very early be aware of the differences between them:
1) ECMAScript : That's the core language JavaScript is based on. That's "just a language".
2) The document object inherits form a lot of different interfaces:
* Node ( http://www.w3.org/TR/DOM-Level-3-Core/core.html#ID-1950641247 ) which is "just here" for the tree structure (ok, well, a bit more). This interface is common with Elements and contains parentNode, cloneNode...
* Document ( http://www.w3.org/TR/DOM-Level-3-Core/core.html#i-Document ) which contains .createElement, .getElementById. This interface is the one used by the .responseXML attribute of XHR. This is common with XML-based documents.
* HTMLDocument ( http://www.w3.org/TR/DOM-Level-2-HTML/html.html#ID-26809268 ). It adds a bunch of HTML-specific things like .body, .links or the .write method (which should be avoided, but that's another story)
* HTML5 redefines the HTMLDocument interface : http://www.whatwg.org/specs/web-apps/current-work/multipage/dom.html#documents-in-the-dom and add for instance .getElementsByClassName()
* Note : I think that understanding that all methods of the document object come from different places helps understanding better the DOM.
3) Events
A lot is captured in this picture : http://www.w3.org/TR/DOM-Level-3-Events/#event-flow
Besides that, the event programming paradigm is not easy to understand. Unlike "C programming" where you have a "main" and a "return" at the end, JavaScript isn't continuously executed. There is a bit of execution at the beginning for initialization purposes and after that it's all user (click/keypress) or network (XHR events) or clock (settimeout) driven which could be all summurized as "events" (even if the clock "events" aren't DOM events)
Providing a function as an argument of another function is somthing that isn't easy to understand. And very quickly arise closures.
I think that understanding all of these elements, the importance of each and the differences between them is fundamental.
NOTES FROM PIPPA/ERIN CALL (25 November)
Javascript
Challenge idea:
Could have a rubric with things that the 'artifact' should include
Peers could review based on the rubric and score? thumbs up?
Challenge or project is not strictly defined, more room for individual flair or personal touch, then assessed against the rubric
Commenting will be key, maybe even something as a line item in the rubric, but also to identify the elements of the assessment
Coding standards for js - already working on these for the community
Build those into the assessment
Encourage good practice around coding - when you check in code, someone will do peer review of the code anyway (if don't meet, won't get accepted in the project)
Help legitimate and motivate assessments
community to define what beginner, intermediate, advanced, expert
descriptions might help up frame the badges moving forward
useful for the new courses list - help them describe the level
Accessibility
haven't heard much about this
identifying what is the user, who are the different parts of usability - who are the users
not just about blind or deaf, but reading issues, localizations issues, slow download speeds
designing a user profile - someone with accessibility problems
tap into resources - people ran an accessibility course in P2PU
what does leveling up look like in this environment
could have them find a website that has bad accessibility - but want more than just identification, want to find people that have built it into the standards.
Chris Harmon - will be at Mozilla
Gradebook
Nils from the assessment workshop
link various things back to the gradebook - submit artifacts from across the web to be assessed
Backpack sort of accomplishes this, since we have the badges that then link out to the artifacts
How would people submit artifacts to be assessed?
Something to ask Josh about it
Working Session
Get in a room together at some point
Maybe second quarter in UK - Webcraft working session
Can we find some other time to get together - maybe to plan for second round of courses?
P2PU working session in NY
NOTE! - November 11's call will be an hour later: 12AM Eastern, 9AM Pacific, 18.00 Central European Time, 17.00 Greenwich Mean Time.
11 November 2010
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Agenda
- P2PU Workshop in Barcelona
- Drumbeat Festival
- Webcraft Toolshed
- Badge Lab
- Other awesome SoW stuff
- School of Webcraft working group
04 November 2010
Drumbeat Festival in Barcelona
28 October 2010
at P2PU Workshop in Barcelona:
21 October 2010
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Agenda
- TShirt Reminder
- Webcraft Toolshed
- School of Webcraft Handbook
- By November 3rd?
- Document Sprint October 30 - November 2
- End of course evaluation
- Webcraft specific questions?
- Updating P2PU Webcraft landing page (Matt)
- http://p2pu.org/webcraft/
- Tech Sprint
- Teaching the Open Web: Festival session & January course proposal
- Dan - how was your course proposal?
- Next Week's call - during Workshop - should we do a report back?
- Booksprint mailing list
Participants
Mattzilla (Toronto)
Danzilla (Ann Arbor,, Michigan)
Janet (Austin)
Pippa (Berlin)
Notes
Drumbeat Fest
WEbcraft Toolshed:
https://wiki.mozilla.org/Drumbeat/events/Festival/program/activities#Webcraft_toolshed
Handbook
* Good to loop End of Course evaluations into this process
* e.g., to feed into an F.A.Q. What was confusing? What questions did you have before the course began?
FAQ:
lightweight ways to update the landing page
priority - introtext (on mockup files)
questions
what can we change - what is P2PU specific
http://tracker.p2pu.org/
Updating P2PU Webcraft landing page:
1) Main nav
2) Intro text
3) Courses / community / Contact us
4) "About Us" links
5) News: possible to pull from Planet Webcraft?
6) Recent courses.
Next Week's Agenda?
- wanted for festival
remind Matt and Pippa of what they should send and pack.
Actions / Waiting On
Matt T to be notified about suggest a course form (PB)
=========================== 14 October 2010 ========================
Agenda
- Goals for January 2011 Round
- Content focus
- Course Numbers
- Participant Numbers
- Localisation
- Webcraft Toolshed at Drumbeat Festival?
- What are our goals for the Festival?
- Stickers ok?
- any other simple promo items
- What message do we want educators, web developers, OWEA and WaSP members to take away?
- Webcraft Charter Feedback
- Evaluation Surveys for courses[Heather]
- Interactive Skills Map
- Greg Wilson from Software Carpentry class http://software-carpentry.org/ (potential January P2PU course?)
- End of semester: "what we learned" / goals for 2011 blog post?
- End of Semester evaluation
Participants
- Dan Diebolt
- Matt Thompson
- Mark Surman
- Pippa Buchanan
- Philipp "relaxed" Schmidt
Links
Webcraft Goals- http://etherpad.mozilla.com:9000/toolshedgoals
Sticker files - https://wiki.mozilla.org/Drumbeat/p2pu/publicity/stickerfiles
Webcraft Charter - http://etherpad.mozilla.org:9000/webcraftcharterdraft (updated)
Notes
- January goals
look at course metrics
course goals
Basic web publication, html, css basic and advanced
use this as base for blogpost and one pager doc
- If you had 2 days with experts of education and web development what would your goals be?
- Sticker feedback":
- School of WEbcraft
- powered by P2PU and Mozilla
- Visit p2pu.org/webcraft
- THIS PAGE NEEDS TO CHANGE...
- School of WEbcraft domain
- Operation "drinking" in effect
- End of Semester blog post
- Can we get end of semester survey and evaluation to work on.
Philipp to provide link to survey account
sound bite / testimonial
MArk: question- who registered v. who completed
branching "did you complete all 6 weeks"
- BArcelona goals - 3 strategic and 3 tactical priorities
Things to Discuss Next Call (21 October 2010)
=========================== 07 October 2010 ========================
Agenda
1. How are your courses going?
2. Maria - looking at Webcraft as model for collection of Mathematics Education
2b. Dan Diebolt - Unsure of relationship of P2PU to Drumbeat Festival
3. Webcraft Charter
http://etherpad.mozilla.org:9000/webcraft-charter (old version)
http://etherpad.mozilla.org:9000/webcraftcharterdraft (updated)
4. Questions?
Participants
- Pippa
- Dan Diebolt
- Maria Droujkova
- Heather James
3. Webcraft Charter
Maria interested in using the charter as a model for the School of Community and Family Mathematics Education
Dan to read, Heather to read too
Link: (above)
4. Student facing information kit
What is P2PU Kit: Slide deck, graphics, elevator pitch for P2PU teachers, sign up / course forms with info on back.
- What is [insert school, e.g., School of Webcraft] in relation to P2PU?
- Who's behind all this? (graphical overview of the charter)
- What to expect from the course? What should I expect to do?
- How does a typical course run? What's different from others?
- How can I get involved? Either: how to find more courses, or how to propose them.
Example introduction to a course:
See screencast from 6:30 (what to expect) and from 8:05 (talking about P2PU) and 10:36 (heirarchical map)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ub7XFT-rsRQ
With 'what is p2pu & school of webcraft'? How is Mozilla supporting this?
etc Centralised set of obligations and community goals
the social contract will be available (eventually)
5. http://www.naturalmath.com/multplanet/index.php
Family example, has a lot of "about" stuff, which I can share for "social agreements"
thanks :-)
6. Task descriptions by rubrics/grids/taxonomies http://ed526b.wikispaces.com/Objectives+grid
=========================== 30 September 2010 ========================
Agenda
1. How are your courses going?
2. Call for courses beginning January 2011
do we want to ask for specific types of courses?
how do we do that?
3. Webcraft Assessment
First technical challenge is HTML
What should the next challenge be? CSS?
4. Webcraft Toolshed in Barcelona
how can we present the course stories in Barcelona?
Do we need more School of Webcraft content?
Participants
1. How are your courses going?
Dan: Allied Media Conference (heard Nathaniel speak)
2 months - when does registration start - unclear from the websites (sorry!)
negative experience until the courses started - communication tools mixed up
consolidate on one place "which tools, which dates, which resources"
courses don't start immediately and gives confusion
still convinced that online learning is part of the future and wants to help improve the site / system.
once in a career, people just want to learnn topics that will help them improve
in Web 200 and HTML5 - being shaped by the peers
happy with pace, content and diversity of backgrounds and skill levels
the questions shape the learning points.
- need to list meeting times, course goals, capacity, sign up times
2. Courses for next round
HTML5 needs to run again, may have other sub topics
html, css, xhmtl , xml, xslt, CMS (drupal, joomla, wordpress -basics and writing extensions), using the cloud, web databases, non-SQL db, couchDB, node.js (javascript server)
oddball: firefox extensions, screenscraping (learn web security through basic scripting)
dan: volunteering to run a course on jQuery - would like a co-host
3. Webcraft Assessment
what next html , css
javascript
how do we enable project based learning?
which will end up as the (absolute, simplest) way to collaborate on project pages together.
editme.com
jottit.com
http://etherpad.mozilla.org:9000/P2PUWD101wk1
http://htmlpad.org/P2PUWD101wk1
=========================== 09 September 2010 ========================
Agenda
1. Mailing Lists
2. Course enrolments - now what?
2a. Entry Evaluation
2b. Early enrollment metrics / testimonials for blog post [Matt]
**Looking for a) total number of applicants b) nice quotes we can use from applications
4. California
5. Webcraft Toolshed
6. Planet Webcraft
** What's the process for adding feeds?
** Who's missing that should be added (e.g., Mark Surman, Matt, others on the call?)
** Encouraging course participants to add their feeds
** Will add Planet Webcraft feed to Drumbeat Project page (Matt)
7. Tweets (#p2pu #mozilla #drumbeat)
8. Heather's news! (heather james - drupal education)
Notes
2. Now What - contact every person, let them know if they are in or not
- be clear
- explain why they are in or not
- let them know when the first class is on
- use http://whenisgood.net
- expect half to not turn up for the first day
- social contract
Metrics / Testimonials
Blog post stating number of applicants
Application letters: do they have good feedback
Matt can help
a) pull the total numbers?
inviting participants to share their blogs (how)
Ari: no of people applied - applied for other courses
John: be clear of time commitment
Ari: wide spectrum of experience with code (total beginners or just new to processing.js)
what to do?
some are also in the processing community
developing games whatever their ability
one hour call for everyone, smaller groups dotted throughout the week
john: a lot of work to balance skills levels
ari: 50 people as intake - not expecting them all to make it the full 6 weeks.
john: be clear of what you need before the first meeting
find out how many will turn up using WhenIsGood - use these numbers to choose whether it's a call or video.
john: those who made the second call stayed the full 6 weeks
give them something to do in advance
1 minute report back, 2 minute report back
conference call: freeconferencecall.com , skype has limits
Matt? Could we use the Mozilla line?
California
dates / times -
Webcraft Toolshed
John: course showcase
short tutorials - jquery (+1 from me)
p2pu dev sprint - showing off, getting people involved
Planet WEbcraft
** What's the process for adding feeds?
email to mailing list / p2pu-dev
can we automate this or at least have a form for adding feeds?
** Who's missing that should be added (e.g., Mark Surman, Matt, others on the call?)
** Encouraging course participants to add their feeds
** Will add Planet Webcraft feed to Drumbeat Project page (Matt)
Heather James
DEveloping WElcome wagon for Drupal
- coding, OER resources for drupal, next round
- pilot course - should we run the course (30 applicants) within P2PU or another environment
- should be self study course with people documenting their progress
- initially 6 week pilot course and more public from November (for anyone to use these resources)
=========================== 02 September 2010 ========================
Agenda items
1. Course applications so far [Pippa]
- Promoting your course?
- Bug in P2PU software? (Web Dev 101 is awesome - but not _that_ popular)
- Any other p2pu.org webtech problems?
2. Webcraft Toolshed at Drumbeat Festival [Pippa, John]
3. Webcraft (and P2PU) Forum environment [Pippa]
- Requirements development - volunteers?
- Django as development framework?
- How to encourage this as a Webcraft Project?
4. Equbay's Project Management course [Pippa]
- Suitable for webcraft?
- Ok for this round or better to incubate for January?
5. W3C [Mark]
Agenda links
Who's on the call
- Josh
- Pippa
- Ahrash
- Ari
- Matt
- Mark
- Equbay
Notes
Pippa: reviewing agenda on https://wiki.mozilla.org/Drumbeat/p2pu/weekly_call/02_September_2010#Agenda_items
Course applications so far [Pippa]
We have a lot of exciting things you can look at spreadsheet (above). Everyone who is adding a course is being added to Web Dev 101, which is a bug? We will see how many actually want to take the course on the 15th.
Mark asks, can you remind us all, what are the targets we want to achieve? How hard should we push?
Pippa: On average we are looking at about 12 people per course. Some people are already oversubscribed such as the Drupal web applicaton that Nicholas is running do not have as many subscribers as we'd like. How can we improve the course description to encourage more people to sign-up?
Pippa: Our goal is to have about 200 people involved.
Q: Should we stop if we reach our goal when we get to 12?
Pippa: no, we should continue to encourage people to sign-up. If we get 30 or 40 people to sign-up then we are likely to get some core group of extremely motivated students that is smaller (closer to 10 to 15).
Pippa: Encouraged a lot of people to sign-up for her course and set-up a community forum to make up for the fact that we do not have one built into p2pu. Is encouraging people to start discussing with people who have already signed-up.
Pippa question: Do we have any other web-tech problems? If you do find a problem while using P2PU website, then you should file a bug in our bugtracker http://tracker.p2pu.org/
Ari: We had one question. Two of us are leading our course. Is it possible or not to have two people be marked as instructors for a course?
Pippa: Not sure. Put it in as a request on the tracker a sa request and send an email to http://groups.google.com/group/p2pu-dev (http://groups.google.com/group/p2pu-dev).
Ahrash: Not so minor really - I think we should absolutely encourage collaborative co-facilitation of courses and make that obvious.
Webcraft Toolshed at Drumbeat Festival [Pippa, John]
Pippa: There is a space for the "webcraft toolshed" at the Drumbeat Festival (http://www.drumbeat.org/drumbeat_festival_2010). How can we use this space?
Ideas on how to use the webcraft toolshed at the Drumbeat Festival and what the Festival is about:
- Pippa: We can use it as a workshop to teach people how to create courses and use the site to run courses.
- Workshopping hacker habits and documenting good web development skills.
- If you had fifty people to do web development, what would you want their help on?
- Bonus points if you come up with a fairly generic problem set that other people could benefit as well.
- Ex: Hackers habits benefit everybody even if they aren't in P2PU.
- Pippa: Working out what the teacher training around the web should be. How can we teach the teachers so they can teach young people on how to use the web.
- Mark: If you have a piece of a curriculum and want to flush something out this is the place to workshop it.
Mark: flagship stream
- anything for webdev education - W3C(Webcraft / OPen Web alliance), Opera all web education tactics
- cohesion in objectives
- crossfertilisation
- workshops and documentation sprints
Ari: We've had 8 or so people who have expressed interest for the course and the majority of them are interested in taking it so they can learn to teach the course. Teachers are interested in learning how to build things for their classrooms; teaching students how to make games.
Pippa: P2PU has such an education audience, it is an education experiment, and so we draw teachers into the conversation ... as well as others such as copyright people and there is a little "preaching to the choir" in that sense.
Webcraft (and P2PU) Forum environment [Pippa]
- Requirements development - volunteers?
- Django as development framework?
- How to encourage this as a Webcraft Project?
- Josh - don't fix on a framework at this (early) point
- work on requirements of behaviour and tech
- types of discussions and how to facilitate
- factors: duration of discussions
- threaded, archived, branch, attached to courses or have their own space?
- Has to integrate with existing tech
- Requirements Document
- DIY or leverage existing tools
Specify time at assessment workshop to discuss these requirements? good P2PU, tech and Webcraft mix.
Ahrash: There has been some confusion on what we want from a discussion thread. What is the scope? Is it course driven? Is it global to the site? How do we want to use it? Where does the demand lie and how do we want to best meet that demand?
Agenda Item: Equbay's Project Management course
https://wiki.mozilla.org/Drumbeat/p2pu/courses/projectmanprinc
Pippa: Concerns that this course relies upon copyrighted materials. Does a) this project management focus relate to webcraft, b) do the copyright restrictiions jive with p2pu?
Equbay: The videos are open and the methodology is universal to any kind of project management.
Mark: The scope of school of webcraft that we are going to promote is about teaching standards based web development. On that basis that this project management topic is a "friendly cousin", it would be an awesome course on its own right, but I'm not sure it passes the test that it relates to "standards based web development."
Mark: is the core material of this course locked down in anyway? Are there trademark restrictions?
Equbay: One interest in this course is to give people an open learning platform for learning this material and not a replacement to provide people a replacement for getting PMI Certification? It would be a complementary course. But, might it be a gateway to certification?
Pippa: We should open this up to the community on the P2PU mailing list. We should bring more people versed in copyright into the conversation.
Mark: Is it possible that P2PU could have assessement that would lead to some form of certification? is there a legal reason we could not certify something?
Equbay: I agree with Pippa, we should move this over to a community discussion and perhaps wait until January before going with the course.
W3C
- Mark: reached out to Open Web Education Alliance
- WaSP curriculums (are open)
- competency maps
- Focussed on University delivery
- using their materials within P2PU
- maintaining and improving
- Webcraft is their term
- Attending in Barcelona
- Webcraft and Mozilla officially involved in OWEA
Pippa: Starting off, I am using some of the WaSP curriculum for my course as a bit of experience. The WaSP curriculum has a wonderful core curriculum and core set of competencies. How do we map their syllaubus onto other, more focused courses (e.g., Python Programming). How can we get these more focused courses take on one ore more of the specific core competencies covered by the WaSP curriculum.
Mark: We need to make it easy for people to have more "uhuh!" moments in terms of who they can collaborate with. We need to find practical, simple ways to make it easy for people to start working together.
Ahrash: One of the ways people try to take a list of competencies and [put them into a learning environment?] is to go ahead and create a fully formed curriculum. One of the problems with this is that often it is hard to get someone to take an entire curriculum and teach it as a course. What excites OWEA about P2PU is that instead of having to take their competencies "wholesale", it would be possible that the core competencies could be mapped to various courses and for their to be an alternative way for people to comprehensively "work through a curriculum".
maybe it's like this?
Step One: I want to be a WEb Developer
vvvvvvv (lots of different ways) vvvvvv
Step Three: Certification! (W3C / Mozilla)
Josh: Suggested that we map competencies to badges.
Pippa: A university focused curriculum might provide a set clear pathway to achieving a degree. But, perhaps what we are offering is an alternative to this more rigid pathway that allows people to choose "mini-pathways" that would allow them be motivated by a "learning on demand" model.
[TO Discuss] charter, certification, testing ground, OWEA, W3C, curriculum v. learning on demand
=========================== 26 August 2010 ==========================
Agenda Items:
- Intro Josh
- September Courses
- Announcement (see links)
- Sign Up
- Courses still to be added
- Thank you!
- Improving January's course proposal and development process
- Webcraft Toolshed at Drumbeat Festival
- Ideas for this space
- improving the webcraft wiki structure on p2pu.org?
- short term workshops (3 hrs) around web techniques?
Agenda links
- etherpad
- Course Announcement Any comments?
Who's on the call
- Pippa
- Philipp
- Matt
- John
- Equbay
- Josh
"Launching" and promoting the September semester
- Classes start: Sep 15
- Sign-up opens: Aug 25
- Sep classes end: Oct 27
Welcome Josh -
September courses
Promotion
drumbeat festival - focus
registration open - Drumbeat will do a post on Planet Mozilla - Monday
Splash feature on front page of Drumbeat.org
Followers
- need the drupal hackers
- higher priority technology fixes
First push - P2PU general push
2nd push on Monday - Webcraft focus / drumbeat / blogs
turn disappointment into action
2nd blog post by Pippa - "this is beta / pilot" is there something missing - let us know.
WEbcraft Toolshed
* extending the P2PU hacking into the Drumbeat Festival
* inviting the public to add ideas.
* extending the skills map - open document - whiteboard
* brainstorming session
Drumbeat Festival
video stream of the festival?
open meetings
many streaming people in barcelona
Josh asked about if we thought about doing some sort of webcast or running an open meeting. He spoke with George Chriss about this idea who is starting a new company called OpenVideo.pro and who also works on the OpenMeetings.org project. He said that since he is a professional it might not be worthwhile in hiring him to do it, since we'd have to fly him out and pay him, etc. But, we might consider contacting the people who are part of the Flumotion project. Josh will attempt follow-up with Flumotion people as well as connect with (Pippa, who should Josh connect with?)
=========================== 12 August 2010 ==========================
Agenda Items:
- "Launching" and promoting the September semester [Matt]
- Defining success / checking in on roadmap
- SXSW (need help getting the word out) [John]
Who's on the call
- Philipp
- Alex
- Matt
- Equbay
- John
"Launching" and promoting the September semester [Matt]
- Classes start: Sep 15
- Sign-up opens: Aug 25
- Sep classes end: Oct 27
Messaging:
- "Coming out party"
- Launching the project in a big way
- Announce sign-up
- Mention that we need January course ideas (but not as main message)
Next step:
- Matt to intro Moz communications crew on webcraft list (Philipp to intro Jane Park)
SXSW
- Panel picker - need your help
- John to blog and tag "mozilla" to get it onto the mozilla planet
- Philipp to blog and get into ocwconsortium / openeducationnews
=========================== 5 August 2010 ==========================
Agenda items
- Webcraft appearance in P2PU.org - how to differentiate [Pippa]
- School of Webcraft title discussion (not crucial - if we have time) [Philipp]
- Technology planning [Philipp]
- Assessment technical implementation [Philipp/Pippa?/Ahrash?]
- Second Hacker Attribute - Community Building [Ahrash]
- what is success for September (participant count etc) [Pippa]
Events heads up:
- Drumbeat NYC - John - Sat 8 August / drumbeat.org
- Drumbeat Copenhagen - Pippa - 20 August / drumbeat.org
Who's on the call
- Pippa
- Ahrash
- Philipp
- Ameet (sp? sorry)
- Xandr
- Equbay
- Alex
- John
Notes
- Pippa and the ether are taking notes
Discussions
Webcraft appearance in P2PU.org - how to differentiate [Pippa]
- Top Navigation bar? SoW box - similar to About Us box.
- Different colors.
- Blue of logo has been sent to Charlie (p2pu dev)
- p2pu.org/webcraft instead of xxx.p2pu.org (subdomaining has search engine implications as well)
- Font styling - should we use the Mozilla font for styling?
- Mozilla branding for each course / icon / logo somewhere
- eg. Web 200 (has a webcraft/mozilla brand + Portuguese icon)
- Use Mozilla logo? within P2PU
- [Philipp] Clarify naming and branding issues with P2PU community (and Mark)
- [Pippa] Reach out to Creative Collective to come up with joint logo / http://creative.mozilla.org/
School of Webcraft title
- Mozilla as webdev training community
- learning opportunities
- primary player in 5 years
- has the name been locked down?
Technical Planning
- Informal so far (John and Philipp)
- Paul Osman
- lead developer on Batacuda (new drumbeat system)
- P2PU overlap
- Drupal v Batacuda v other tech
- should list requirements before identifying tech
- Xandr: drupal (probably) not the way to go
- [Xandr] to try and identify a few people to pull into this conversation
- MoCo web dev
- Important to keep backend dev as open and transparent as possible
- Major advantage of Drupal is that it draws on open community
- Important to make site code available to other developers
- Setting up dev server and anonymised database content / basic process and anonymized database now exist - still pretty rough (http://tracker.p2pu.org/website/node/196)
- Alex: should process development as a case study for SoW students
- Alex: Also worthwhile (but a lot of work) to document the "process" by which the new system is created
Assessment technical implementation [Ahrash]
- Good at answering questions https://wiki.mozilla.org/Drumbeat/p2pu/Assessment_and_Accreditation/Webcraft_Assessments_-_detailed/Answer_questions
- overlaps with good bedside manners (not "i'm sorry but your idea sucks")
- metrics based
- feedback
- comments and answers can be rated
- ("this was helpful") see Amazon reviews
- Turned on by default
- Community involvement (https://wiki.mozilla.org/Drumbeat/p2pu/Assessment_and_Accreditation/Webcraft_Assessments_-_detailed/Community_builder)
- less objectively measured
- many ways of measuring
- many types of being
- participants could pick certain attributes
- or do looser measures
- eg. opinion polls at end of course
- At this point tech not fixed - so we are playing around a bit - important to remind users of this as well.
- Focus on aspect of the assessment models / metrics that are tech-light, but idea/concept heavy
- Might have to do with some manual metrics, and less automated metrics
- leverage the peers - actual people!
- to encourage: measuring and evaluating soft skills is of equal importance
- Philipp: important to have both technical metric based measurement as well as socially sourced feedback.
- Ahrash: if community builder is high level moniker with many flavours
- identify subset of main behaviours
- Use community evaluation to help us refine definition of community builders. If someone gets high peer score, we could investigate how they behave in the course (frequency of posting, etc.) and correlate it.
- We should do this for both, community builder and ability to answer question
- great research paper for both online education and other academic fields
- equbay: can be used for other fields eg management
- Ahrash: we have a nice group to do the research in and resources to do the development within SoW. able to move to other fields
- Equbay: should we be specifically teaching these soft skills within courses?
What is success in September [Pippa]
- Courses:
- 12-15 courses realistic for Sep
- Goal: Roughly 10 (-15?) people per course / about 100 - 150
- What happens if we have more applications?
- Up to the course organizers - Yes!
- Course organizers specifies target size, but then are free to change their mind - accept 3 people, or 10 or anybody who applied
- How many applicants do we expect?
- Need a backup plan to incubate applicants we can't accept
- [Philipp to speak with Alison] Add something about "superlurkers" to orientation
- Mailing list for participants for future rounds?
- 180 people signed up to the webcraft list already
- 40-60% of participants join the community afterwards? (This is probably too low)
- Course evaluation
- Both so track participation, expectations, pre/post
- Add questions to the existing post course survey for next round
- Find someone to work on evaluation
- 180 people already signed up
- Philipp: be careful that we don't get expectations set beyond what we can achieve.
- careful communication around sign up for courses.
- clear wording on what we are offering / community
- Philipp: fine line between acceptance and non-acceptance
- still see communications
- can view live feed
- superlurking badge?
January 2011
- Jetpack for learning - model for organising over Holidays / NY / Summer in The South
- Call for courses and orientation before christmas
- courses to start January 10